| 2nd Period Play-by-Play |
| | End of period [90:00]. |
| [89:31] | Offside against OTT. |
| | Foul on OTT. |
| | Foul on CAP. |
| | Foul on CAP. |
| [85:12] | OTT substitution: Adam Brown for Kurt Gallant. |
| [85:02] | Shot by OTT Byron Horton WIDE. |
| [84:31] | Shot by OTT Dustin Kiaski BLOCKED. |
| | Foul on CAP. |
| [82:44] | Offside against CAP. |
| [82:04] | OTT substitution: Dustin Kiaski for Matthew Aardema. |
| [82:04] | CAP substitution: Jacob Strickler for Brian Zembower. |
| [82:04] | CAP substitution: Jason Rothwell for Jeremy Sampson. |
| [81:19] | Shot by CAP Mike Gregory, SAVE David Dziedzicki. |
| | Foul on OTT. |
| | Foul on OTT. |
| [75:04] | CAP substitution: Brian Zembower for Ian Warmbrodt. |
| [75:04] | CAP substitution: Cameron VanTilburg for Steven McCarthy. |
| [74:42] | Shot by OTT Seth Holland, SAVE Justin Bultman. |
| | Foul on CAP. |
| [70:46] | Shot by CAP Denny Napier WIDE. |
| [70:41] | Shot by CAP Steven McCarthy BLOCKED. |
| [70:13] | CAP substitution: Mike Gregory for Ryan Cieply. |
| [70:07] | Corner kick by CAP Daniel McCarthy. |
| [67:26] | Corner kick by OTT Dustin Kiaski. |
| [67:06] | Corner kick by OTT Dustin Kiaski. |
| [66:35] | Corner kick by OTT Dustin Kiaski. |
| | *picked up loose ball at top of box beat keeper to top left corner |
| Capital Crusaders 2, Otterbein 0 |
| [65:45] | GOAL by CAP Ian Warmbrodt. |
| | Foul on OTT. |
| [60:52] | Corner kick by CAP Daniel McCarthy. |
| [60:15] | Shot by CAP Daniel McCarthy, SAVE David Dziedzicki. |
| [57:16] | Yellow card on OTT Harrison Jones. |
| | *breakaway on right side beat goalie low from 20 yards out |
| Capital Crusaders 1, Otterbein 0 |
| [55:46] | GOAL by CAP Ian Warmbrodt (FIRST GOAL). |
| [55:17] | OTT substitution: Byron Horton for Brandon Shepherd. |
| [55:17] | OTT substitution: Matthew Aardema for Seth Holland. |
| [54:57] | Shot by OTT Tyler Daniels, SAVE Justin Bultman. |
| [54:14] | Shot by CAP Daniel McCarthy WIDE LEFT. |
| | Foul on OTT. |
| [53:25] | Offside against OTT. |
| [52:50] | CAP substitution: Ryan Cieply for Mike Gregory. |
| [52:25] | Corner kick by OTT Greg Atkinson. |
| | Foul on OTT. |
| | Foul on CAP. |
| [49:32] | Shot by OTT Harrison Jones HIGH. |
| | Foul on CAP. |
| | Foul on CAP. |
| | Start of 2nd period [45:00]. |
